BENERU
Cash flow and yieldsPublished

If I save the amount of my depreciation, will it cover a future rebuild or major repairs?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

Ritsu SakakibaraFinancial product examiner

This is Ritsu Sakakibara. I will give the conclusion first.

Not necessarily. Depreciation is the cost of acquiring a building (its acquisition cost) allocated to the necessary expenses of each year over its useful life. Its basis of calculation is different from the cost of a future rebuild or major repairs. Depreciation is also an expense that involves no cash outflow in that year (the money was paid when the building was acquired), and no money of that amount is set aside anywhere.

What is decided, and how

  • Buildings acquired on or after April 1, 2007 (Heisei 19) are depreciated by the straight-line method (building fixtures and structures acquired on or after April 1, 2016 (Heisei 28) also use the straight-line method)
  • Straight-line depreciation is calculated as "acquisition cost × straight-line depreciation rate". The acquisition cost is the purchase price plus the costs of putting the asset into business use
  • For newly built residential buildings, the useful life is 22 years for wooden and synthetic-resin construction, and 47 years for reinforced concrete and steel-reinforced concrete construction
  • The part of a repair treated as a capital expenditure is not an expense of that year; it goes into each year's necessary expenses through depreciation

In other words, depreciation looks at an amount paid in the past. Future changes in prices and construction costs are not part of the calculation.

What to compare

ItemDepreciationFuture construction cost
Base amountAcquisition cost at the time of acquisitionPrice at the time of the work
Changes in prices and construction costsNot reflectedReflected
Cash movementAn expense with no cash outflowCash is needed when the work is done
TimingEvery year over the useful lifeAll at once, when the work is done

Where the answer splits (calculation)

The following is an assumption for illustration. Suppose you acquire a newly built wooden apartment building for ¥22 million. The straight-line depreciation rate for a 22-year useful life is 0.046, so depreciation is about ¥1.01 million a year, and the total over 22 years is the acquisition cost minus ¥1 (about ¥22 million). Below, the cost of rebuilding a building of the same size after 22 years is set for each annual rate of increase in construction costs (demolition, design fees and the loss of rent during the rebuild are not included).

Annual increase in construction costs (assumed)Construction cost after 22 yearsPer year, divided over 22 yearsDifference from total depreciation
0%¥22 million¥1.0 million¥0
1%about ¥27.38 millionabout ¥1.245 millionabout ¥5.38 million
2%about ¥34.01 millionabout ¥1.546 millionabout ¥12.01 million
3%about ¥42.15 millionabout ¥1.916 millionabout ¥20.15 million

The rate of increase is an assumption, not a forecast. For reference, in material from the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism (estimates of planned housing investment in new construction), the planned construction cost per unit of new rental housing was ¥10.24 million in fiscal 2021 (Reiwa 3) and ¥14.05 million in fiscal 2025 (Reiwa 7), about 1.37 times over 4 years (about 8.2% a year as an annual rate). However, these are planned amounts at the time construction was notified. Because they are averages per unit, changes in unit size or in the mix of building structures also show up in the numbers. They are not a figure showing that the unit price of the same building rose by this much.

Conditions behind the numbers

  • The depreciation rules follow the National Tax Agency's explanation based on laws and regulations as of April 1, 2026 (Reiwa 8)
  • The calculation is fictional, and depreciation is rounded. A building acquired second-hand may have a shorter useful life, in which case annual depreciation is larger and the period shorter
  • Interest on the money saved and taxes are not included in the calculation
  • The planned construction costs are values from the reference material of the Building Construction Statistics report (September 2026 (Reiwa 8) data) published on October 30, 2026

Order of checks

  1. In the depreciation breakdown of your tax return, check the building's acquisition cost, useful life and remaining years
  2. Set the timing of the rebuild or major repairs, and today's estimate
  3. Set the rate of increase in construction costs as a range (for example 0%, 2% and 4%) and work out the amount at the time of the work
  4. Divide that amount by the number of years until the work, and make it an annual savings amount separate from depreciation
  5. Check whether that savings amount can come out of the money left after principal repayments and taxes

From here on, this is my opinion

I think depreciation is an allocation for calculating income, not a figure for financial planning. If you use depreciation as a guide for savings, it will drift toward a shortfall whenever construction costs are rising. I think it is better to set the savings amount separately from depreciation, working backward from an estimate of the future construction cost.

Sources (in Japanese)

RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita.

"The depreciation amount" — where exactly is that money? Open your bankbook and you won't find a balance with that name anywhere.

No, I get what you mean. Depreciation is an expense, but no money leaves that year. So "that amount should still be in hand, and if I save it, it'll pay for renewing the building." The idea of saving is right. It's right — but setting how much to save by the depreciation amount is the bug.

Answer first. Whether it's enough is decided with no connection to depreciation.

One. Depreciation is, roughly, the price of the building on the day you bought it divided by a number of years. I read words by cutting them into pieces, so when "depreciation" and "savings" sit in the same sentence, the first thing that snags is that one is a past price and the other is a future price. The invoice for work 15 years from now arrives at the price of 15 years from now. However carefully you divide the price on the day you bought it, it won't reach that. Get it?

Two. The money matching depreciation isn't all still there in the first place. Principal repayments on the loan aren't an expense, but the cash still goes out, so the cash depreciation supposedly freed up gets cut down first by principal repayments. The following is an assumption for illustration. If depreciation is ¥1 million a year and principal repayment is ¥800,000 a year, then looking at depreciation alone, the cash left over is ¥200,000 after subtracting. If tax is charged on the profit, money goes out there too. OK?

Now the real point. So how do you decide the savings amount? Reverse the order.

Continuing the assumption. In 15 years, work on the outer walls and roof comes due, and today's estimate is ¥6 million. If construction costs rise 0% a year it's still ¥6 million in 15 years; at 2% a year it's about ¥8.08 million; at 4% a year about ¥10.81 million. Divided over 15 years, the annual savings are ¥400,000, about ¥540,000, and about ¥720,000. The rate of increase isn't a forecast, it's an assumption, so set it as a range.

And no comparing these numbers with the ¥1 million of depreciation and saying "it's enough." What you compare them with isn't depreciation; it's the money actually left after paying principal and taxes. From depreciation alone that's ¥200,000 in our assumption, which doesn't even reach the ¥400,000 for the 0% case. Am I wrong?

Let's sort it out once. Set the future construction cost from today's estimate and a range of rates of increase. Divide by the number of years until the work. See whether that can come out of the cash left over after principal repayments and taxes. Depreciation doesn't appear anywhere in this calculation. The only place it appears is in calculating the tax that reduces the cash left over.

Oysters, too — even if you carefully keep last year's receipt, you can't buy this year's oysters at that price. Receipts go in the books; shopping is done with the wallet.

Read a little deeper