BENERU
Law, contracts and systemsPublished Updated

If an apartment building I inherited has a tenant with no written contract, can I have them move out?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

Ritsu SakakibaraFinancial product examiner

This is Ritsu Sakakibara. I will give the conclusion first. Even without a written contract, if the tenant pays rent and lives there, the principle is to consider that a lease contract has been formed. The person who inherited the property takes over the lessor's position as it is. To have the tenant move out, you need either to meet the legal requirements or the tenant's agreement.

What is decided

  • A lease takes effect through an agreement to lend, to borrow and pay rent, and to return the property when it ends (Civil Code Article 601). A written document is not a requirement.
  • An heir succeeds to all of the rights and obligations of the deceased (Civil Code Article 896). This includes the lessor's position.
  • If no rent is being received, it may be treated not as a lease but as a loan for use. The treatment changes, so check this first.

Requirements for the lessor to end the lease

If an agreement fixing a term cannot be confirmed, or if the term has expired and the lease has been renewed by statutory renewal (Article 26, paragraph 1), it is treated as a lease without a fixed term.

ItemContent (Act on Land and Building Leases (Shakuchi Shakuya Hō))
When it endsIt ends 6 months after notice of termination (Article 27, paragraph 1)
What is neededJust cause (Article 28)
What is considered for just causeThe circumstances in which each party needs the building, the history so far, the use and current condition of the building, and any offer of a financial payment such as a moving-out fee

The building being old is one of the circumstances considered, but that alone does not necessarily establish just cause.

Can it be switched to a fixed-term lease?

  • A residential lease that has continued since before March 1, 2000 (Heisei 12) cannot be switched to a fixed-term building lease, even if both parties agree. The Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism states this explicitly.
  • Even for leases after that date, a fixed-term building lease requires a contract in writing (including electromagnetic records) (Article 38, paragraphs 1 and 2). The fact that there is no renewal must be explained in advance by delivering a document. If it is not explained, the provision that there is no renewal is invalid (Article 38, paragraphs 3 and 5).

Who conducts the negotiation

The choice is the lessor themselves or an attorney. Article 72 of the Attorney Act prohibits anyone who is not an attorney from handling legal affairs as a business for the purpose of receiving remuneration. In a decision of July 20, 2010 (Heisei 22), the Supreme Court found that the offense under that Article was established for persons without attorney qualifications who, on commission from a building's owner, negotiated with lessees to have them move out, holding that it was a case in which a legal dispute was almost unavoidable.

Order of checks

  1. Check how rent is received and since when, using the bankbook and similar records.
  2. Check when the tenancy began. Whether it was before March 1, 2000 (Heisei 12) changes whether a switch to a fixed-term building lease is possible.
  3. Check the current condition of the building, and whether fire insurance is in place for the building and for the tenant's household goods.
  4. Put the contract terms in writing and show them to the tenant.

From here on, this is my opinion

Before thinking about having the tenant move out, I think you should first settle the current contractual relationship in writing. That is the starting point both for judging the requirements and for any material for negotiation.

Sources (in Japanese)

RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. Say you come across a line like "We handle all the tedious move-out negotiations on your behalf." First, let's chew on that line.

Answer first. The only two choices for who plays your side in the negotiation are you yourself or an attorney. And before deciding which, the first thing to decide is whether a negotiation is even needed.

Reason one. Article 72 of the Attorney Act prohibits people who aren't attorneys from handling legal affairs as a business for the purpose of receiving remuneration. Getting someone who pays rent and lives there to leave is a field where, if it goes wrong, it obviously turns into a legal dispute. So that "on your behalf" line — fine if an attorney is doing it, but if not, the sign itself is full of holes. Don't you get it? The person who hired them thinks they "left it to a pro," but legally, they left it to someone they weren't allowed to leave it to.

Reason two. For the lessor to end a building lease, you need just cause under the Act on Land and Building Leases. In other words, moving out is something that starts with "asking," not something you can order.

Now the real point. The question is "an attorney or myself," but the fork before that is missing. What do you want to do with this building? If you want to keep renting it out, no move-out negotiation is needed. If you want to sell it with the tenant in place, that's not needed either. The buyer just prices it as "a building people live in." A negotiation is needed only when you empty it to rebuild, or empty it to sell. Depending on which of these three it is, what you need is completely different. Keeping up?

No, well, I get the voice on the other side too. "Attorneys are expensive, can't I just talk to them myself?" Right, that's right, but if you talk yourself, the other side is someone who has lived there a long time, and you're the newcomer who just inherited. What you say out loud stays as a promise, as is. I think the value of paying an attorney's fees to hand it over is that you can put someone in between who can measure the weight of words. On the other hand, if you keep renting or sell with the tenant in place, honestly, the negotiation cost is zero. If you're comparing expensive and cheap, that's what you should compare it with.

So the first thing to do isn't opening the phone book. Write one line on paper: "What do I want to do with this building, and in how many years?" Keep renting, sell with the tenant in place, empty it and rebuild, empty it and sell. Which one you write decides whether you need an attorney, and when to hire one. Am I wrong?

You know daikon in oden — if you throw it into the pot without parboiling it first, the flavor doesn't soak in properly. Rather than jumping into the pot with who to hire, do the prep first based on what you want to make. See ya.

Sources (in Japanese)

(Updated 2026.10.15)

Read a little deeper