BENERU
Financing and interest ratesPublished Updated

Is falsification of investment loan documents happening at banks other than the one in the news?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

Ritsu SakakibaraFinancial product examiner

This is Ritsu Sakakibara. I will give the conclusion first. Falsification of investment loan documents is not limited to the one bank that was in the news. In material published by the Financial Services Agency in 2019, cases were confirmed in which other lenders also made loans without detecting falsification of documents by the real estate businesses bringing in customers. However, who mainly did the falsifying and how the lender was involved differ from case to case.

The Financial Services Agency's survey (published March 2019)

ItemDetails
Covered121 banks, 261 shinkin banks, 148 credit cooperatives (questionnaire in October and November 2018)
Method of falsificationReal estate-related businesses falsified customers' bankbooks, withholding tax statements and other documents to disguise their assets and income
Cases confirmedCases where, even without the lender's own involvement or tacit approval, it executed a loan without detecting falsification by the real estate business bringing in the customer
Weaknesses in screeningMany lenders received documents on customers' assets and income through the businesses. Many lenders also did not thoroughly check originals
Loans to customers brought in by businessesFrom April 2015 to March 2018, 97% of banks and 79% of shinkin banks and credit cooperatives had executed whole-building loans to customers brought in by businesses (based on valid responses)

The same report says it is necessary to fully take into account that, if a property's income and expenses turn negative, the investor themselves may suffer the losses.

What remains with the borrower

The National Consumer Affairs Center of Japan says that if you misstate your annual income, assets, purpose of use or similar when taking out a loan, the lender may demand repayment in a lump sum. Even if a business instructed you to make the false statement, the obligation to repay lies with the borrower. Even if it was the business that falsified the documents, the party to the loan contract is the borrower.

Order of checks

  1. Do not leave originals such as bankbooks and withholding tax statements with the business. Prepare the documents you submit to the lender yourself.
  2. Before signing, check that the annual income, own funds and purpose of borrowing on the application are true.
  3. Compare the rents on the rent roll received from the seller against asking rents in the area and, if you can obtain them, records of deposits.
  4. If you are told to make a statement that differs from the facts, stop the transaction at that point.

From here on, this is my opinion

I think the idea that "the lender approved the loan, so this property is fine" should be abandoned. What the Financial Services Agency's material showed is that passing screening does not mean the documents are correct. The one who can finally check the numbers in the documents is the borrower.

Sources (in Japanese)

RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. Backwards, it's backwards. "At banks other than the one in the news?" — starting from the bank's name makes it harder to see. The hole wasn't in the bank's signboard; it was in the route the documents take.

I'll say it first. It was happening. The questionnaire survey material the Financial Services Agency published in 2019 says that the Financial Services Agency's monitoring found cases where other lenders also made loans without detecting materials falsified by the businesses bringing in customers.

Here's why. The borrower's bankbook and withholding tax statement reach the bank by passing through the business's hands. Even if the numbers get rewritten along the way, what reaches the counter is only the paper after the rewrite. The same material says many lenders received income and asset documents through the businesses, and many did not thoroughly check originals. If the route is the same, the same thing happens even with a different signboard. A bit tricky? Well, hang in there.

So, here's the real point. I suspect falsification often moves along without the borrower even noticing. Few people say "Let's pad your income" to your face; it comes with a kind face, like "We'll get the paperwork together for you" or "We'll hold on to your bankbook." The borrower thinks, great, that saved me trouble. It's a sad story. This part, OK?

Now the other side. Isn't it the bank's fault for not catching it, in the end? Yes, lax screening was the bank's problem. I won't give ground on that. But even if the bank's fault comes out later, that doesn't make your own loan contract disappear. The bank's fault and your contract are on separate books. Am I getting through?

So what you should care about isn't the bank's name but who is sitting between you and the bank. The way to check is to match up the entrance and the exit of the route. Go to the loan interview and the contract signing yourself, and ask the bank's person in charge, "Could you show me here the income and deposit documents used in the screening?" Is the paper you gave the business the same as the paper that reached the bank? If numbers you don't recognize come out, put the pen down right there. If you're told "You can skip the interview," honestly, that itself is the answer.

Napa cabbage, you know, sometimes the outer leaves look nice but the core is going bad. Anyone can see the outer leaves at the shop, but only the person who bought it and took it home cuts it open to the core. If you're going to cut it, do it before it goes in the hot pot.

Sources (in Japanese)

(Updated 2026.10.15)

Read a little deeper