BENERU
Repairs and buildingsPublished

If a building is "shin-taishin" (built under the post-1981 earthquake-resistance standards), are its piles also designed to withstand earthquakes?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

Ritsu SakakibaraFinancial product examiner

This is Ritsu Sakakibara. I will give the conclusion first.

No. The new earthquake-resistance standards of 1981 were not the dividing line at which seismic design of piles became mandatory. Figures assuming the sideways force of an earthquake (horizontal force) on piles were set in 2001 (MLIT Notice No. 1113 of 2001 (Heisei 13)), and the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism's draft guidelines say that seismic design of foundation piles is "generally" regarded as having become mandatory at this point. You cannot say "it's shin-taishin, so the piles are probably fine too" from the year alone.

What is decided, and how

On October 30, 2026, the Building Guidance Division of the Ministry's Housing Bureau began inviting public comments on the "Guidelines (Draft) for Verification and Retrofitting Against Overturning of Buildings with Foundation Piles" (the deadline is 9:30 on November 29, 2026). This follows damage in the 2024 (Reiwa 6) Noto Peninsula Earthquake in which a reinforced concrete building overturned; the overturned building was built in 1972, under the so-called old earthquake-resistance standards. The draft guidelines summarize the history of the rules on foundations and piles as follows.

PeriodWhat was decidedProvision for earthquakes in piles
1971 (Ministry of Construction Notice No. 111 of 1971 (Showa 46))Allowable bearing capacity of pilesOnly rules assuming vertical load (the weight of the building)
1981 (new earthquake-resistance standards)Seismic force on underground parts (Article 88 of the Order for Enforcement of the Building Standards Act)The first rule related to seismic design of foundations
1984 (Jūshi-hatsu No. 324 of 1984 (Showa 59))"Design Guidelines for Building Foundations Against Seismic Force"Long treated as something "to be recommended, for the time being, as a standard of desirable level"
2001 (MLIT Notice No. 1113 of 2001 (Heisei 13))Figures such as allowable stress assuming horizontal force on pilesGenerally regarded as having become mandatory here

According to the draft guidelines, no overturning damage to buildings with foundation piles has been reported for buildings from 2001 onward.

What to compare

For pile-foundation buildings from before the 2001 notice, the draft guidelines treat them as follows.

State of the buildingTreatment in the draft guidelines
No documents showing seismic design of the pilesTreated as not having had seismic design of the piles
Pile type unknownAs a rule, assumed to be precast concrete piles (PC piles)
Diagnosed and reinforced under the Act on Promotion of Seismic Retrofitting of BuildingsIf the review did not include the foundation and piles, treated as not having had seismic design of the piles

What is easily overlooked is the last row. Even if "seismic reinforcement is done", if the scope of the diagnosis was only the upper structure, the piles are treated as having no seismic design. The treatment when documents exist is not stated clearly in the draft guidelines, so you end up checking the contents of the documents.

Where the answer splits

The draft guidelines first look at whether the building meets a foundation condition. There are three: (a) the piles have seismic design, (b) piles with high ductility (cast-in-place concrete piles, SC piles, steel pipe piles, etc.) are used, (c) the entire area below the 1st floor is a basement level. If none apply, they look at the upper-structure conditions (a shape in which the effect of overturning is small, a plan unlikely to produce uneven vertical loads, and highly redundant support conditions), and if those do not apply either, the possibility of overturning is verified.

The guide for a shape in which the effect of overturning is small is an aspect ratio (height from ground level ÷ apparent width of the frame) of 2.5 or less. The following is an assumption for illustration. For a building 25 m tall, in the direction where the apparent width is 9 m, 25 ÷ 9 = about 2.78, which exceeds 2.5. In the direction where the apparent width is 11 m, it is about 2.27. Even for the same building, the number changes if it has a narrow direction. Separately, the guide for highly redundant support conditions is 3 or more spans; if the number differs by frame, the judgment is made on the smallest number of spans.

Conditions behind the numbers

  • As of November 2, 2026, the draft guidelines are a draft open for public comment. The conditions and positioning may change in the final version. The introduction says it is "desirable to apply them and carry out a review", and they are not written as an obligation.
  • The draft guidelines say that overturning is "very rare damage" resulting from overlapping factors, and that it cannot be said that all buildings built before the current standards are immediately dangerous. They also say that the foundation conditions are basically information for setting the priority of surveys, and are not something that can reliably prevent overturning.
  • The aspect ratio calculation uses assumed numbers. They are not values for a real building.

Order of checks

  1. Check the date of building confirmation (certificate of confirmation) and when construction started (construction records, etc.), and see which side of the two lines, 1981 (new earthquake-resistance standards) and 2001 (Notice No. 1113), the building is on
  2. Check whether it has a pile foundation, and whether structural drawings and pile specifications (pile type, whether there was seismic design) remain. For a condominium unit, ask the owners' association
  3. If there are records of seismic diagnosis or retrofitting, see in the report whether the scope of the review included the foundation and piles
  4. In the explanation of important matters, if a building whose new construction started before June 1, 1981 has had a seismic diagnosis, its contents are explained (Article 16-4-3, Item 5 of the Ordinance for Enforcement of the Building Lots and Buildings Transaction Business Act). The 2001 line is separate from the dividing line for this explanation

From here on, this is my opinion

I think it is good to remember the two separately: 1981 is the line for the upper structure, and 2001 is the line for piles. Since a building without documents is treated as having "no seismic design", for pile-foundation buildings from before 2001, whether the documents remain affects how the building is evaluated. The draft guidelines do not touch on the cost of retrofitting or the effect on price. When the final version is issued, I will review the conditions of this answer.

Sources (in Japanese)

(Updated 2026.11.02)
Drunken WangLiving memory of the times

This is Wang. The "1981" of shin-taishin is a line drawn for the building above. The line for the piles is generally regarded as having been drawn 20 years later, in 2001.

The draft guidelines the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism began inviting comments on on October 30, 2026 lay out that history. In the notice of 1971 (Showa 46), piles were thought of only as holding up the weight of the building. With shin-taishin in 1981, the force of an earthquake on the underground part was set for the first time. In 1984 (Showa 59), guidelines for foundation design came out too, but for a long time they were treated as something "to be recommended, for the time being, as a standard of desirable level". It was in 2001 (Heisei 13) that figures assuming sideways force on piles were set in a notice.

Something written as "desirable", people rarely keep to. Long ago a doctor told me too, "It is desirable to cut back on drinking", and I thought, yes, quite desirable. I only thought it. That very night I had one cup of kaoliang liquor — no, was it 3? Kakakaka.

Back to it. In the 2024 (Reiwa 6) Noto Peninsula Earthquake, a reinforced concrete building fell over on its side. It was built in 1972, in the days of the old standards. According to the draft, among buildings from 2001 onward, there have been no reports of a building with piles falling over.

But the draft doesn't say every building from before 2001 is dangerous. It says the overturning was "very rare damage" where several factors overlapped. Buildings where everything below the 1st floor is basement, buildings whose shape isn't tall and skinny, and buildings with room to spare in how the columns are arranged, it counts on the side whose survey can come later in the order. It doesn't say that means they certainly won't fall, mind you.

People have always been this way: once they learn one line, they want to settle everything with it. Learn "after '81 it's fine", and they throw the piles and the walls in there too. But the lines have been redrawn with every earthquake. The line above and the line below have different years.

When you look at a building with piles from before 2001, just ask one thing: "Do the pile drawings still exist?" The draft treats a building without drawings as one where "no seismic design of the piles was done". If there are drawings, you can look further; if there aren't, that too is an answer.

Choose sake by how smooth it goes down, and you'll weep with your stomach the next morning. With buildings too, don't choose by the taste at the top alone.

Sources (in Japanese)

(Updated 2026.11.02)

Read a little deeper