BENERU
Repairs and buildingsPublished

How should I deal with tenants during major repairs on a condominium building?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. Dealing with tenants during major repairs isn't a story about apologies; it's a story about a calculation to keep the loss small.

I mean, apologies are needed. Explaining things politely is a given, too. But if you treat it as a matter of feelings, the owner can't decide "what to do, and how far." So make it a formula.

Let's sort out the spec. The money an owner might lose during the work is roughly this: rent reduction × months + extra months of vacancy if someone moves out × rent + any allowance you offer. The sum of those three. If you decide by looking at only one of them, the other terms swell.

First term, rent reduction. The Civil Code has a rule that if part of a unit becomes unusable for a reason not attributable to the lessee, the rent is reduced in proportion to the part that became unusable. But you can't hang laundry on the balcony, it's hard to open the windows, it's noisy during the day. What share of the unit that amounts to isn't written in the article. This part's a bit tricky. There's the view that you can still live in the unit even if the balcony can't be used, so the share is small, and for someone working from home, the daytime noise weighs more. Get it?

Second term, vacancy. Suppose a tenant moves out of a unit with ¥80,000 rent during the work. A building wrapped in scaffolding and sheeting makes a bad impression at viewings, so if a unit that usually gets taken in 1 month takes 2.5 months, the extra vacancy is 1.5 months, ¥120,000.

Now put the two side by side. Suppose you lower the rent by 5% for just 2 months; that reduces income by ¥8,000. Wow, that's 1/15 of ¥120,000. Of course, lowering it doesn't mean they won't move out. But if it lowers the chance of them moving out because of the work even a little, it can be a cheap allowance. Am I wrong?

Third term, allowances. Even without a reduction, there's covering the cost of a laundry dryer, delivering the work schedule regularly, fitting the days the workers enter the unit around the tenant's convenience. Quite a few items cost no money at all.

Then there's a variable outside the formula. Does the work period overlap with the renewal period? If the renewal month falls right in the middle of the work, you're showing the most inconvenient view at exactly the moment they decide whether to keep living there. As soon as you know the work schedule, just lining it up against the tenants' renewal months lets you read the vacancy term pretty well. You know?

I mean, plenty of times things settle fine without doing this calculation every time. But scrambling to think after you're asked for a reduction, versus going into the conversation with the formula already in hand — the way the discussion settles is different.

You know buri daikon (yellowtail and radish)? Until the flavor soaks into the radish, the kitchen is taken over by the pot the whole time. But if you tell the family waiting, "it'll be another so many minutes," nobody comes to complain. What? The yellowtail is the real star? Oh, is that so.

Sources (in Japanese)

  • デジタル庁(e-Gov法令検索)「民法」(checked 2026-10-14)
Jamie GooInvestor in training

Hey, it's Jamie! A prospective tenant who came for a viewing stopped in front of the building and just went home. After looking up at the building wrapped all around in scaffolding and sheeting. That really happened when I was advertising my unit!

About 1 month after major repair work started on the building where I own a condominium unit, my tenant told me they were moving out. A job transfer, they said. It was a relief that it wasn't because of the work, but there were still 4 months of work left.

So I took a look at an online forum where fellow owners gather. When I posted "What do you do about advertising during the work?" the replies were almost all the same. "Everyone just advertises normally." "You don't need to go out of your way to mention the work." "Keeping the rent the same is fine too." Oh, so that's what everyone does! I thought, and I went right along with it. The listing photos were the bright photos of the unit from last time, and the rent stayed at ¥75,000. I told the person at the property management company, "Same as usual, please."

The result was the scene I just described. In the photos it's a sunny unit, but when you come, the building is inside sheeting and outside the window there's scaffolding. Even inside the unit it's dim in the daytime, and you can hear the construction. Can't blame them for thinking it's different from the photos. There was also 1 time when I thought an application had come in, and then it was withdrawn after they heard how long the work would last.

In the end, it took 3 months until the next person was settled. ¥75,000 rent × 3 months is ¥225,000. Usually it got taken in about 1 month, so that means about ¥150,000 extra that didn't come in.

I don't think the people on the forum were lying. Some buildings finish their work quickly, and some units near the station get taken no matter what. "Everyone's" units and my unit had different conditions. Thinking I couldn't go wrong if I did the same as everyone, without checking that, was my mistake in judgment.

Partway through, I talked with the person at the property management company and changed the approach. We had the listing state when the work would finish, with a note that "once the scaffolding comes down, the exterior walls will be new too." We also added a condition lowering the first month's rent a little. It was after that that it got taken.

Three things I'd like to tell myself back then.

  • When a tenant says they're moving out, first think about it alongside the remaining work period
  • Have the listing state the work period and when it will finish
  • Recheck "everyone does it" against your own unit's conditions

Even now, whenever I see a building with scaffolding in front of Koiwa Station, I can't help looking for a for-rent notice. The other day the man at the greengrocer asked me, "Young man, are you buying the building?" I can't afford it!

Read a little deeper