BENERU
Financing and interest ratesPublished Updated

Why shouldn't you buy an investment property with Flat 35?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

Ritsu SakakibaraFinancial product examiner

This is Ritsu Sakakibara. I will give the conclusion first. Flat 35 is a housing loan for funds to acquire a home in which the borrower or a relative will live, and it cannot be used to buy an investment property. Borrowing while hiding an investment purpose is a breach of contract, and the Japan Housing Finance Agency states that if improper use comes to light, it will demand repayment of the loan in a lump sum.

Differences between what Flat 35 covers and an investment loan

ItemFlat 35Investment loan
CoversA home in which the borrower or a relative livesA property for rent
Interest rateGenerally lowOften higher than Flat 35
ScreeningStandards for a homeAlso looks at the property's profitability
Renting to othersNot assumed, in principleAssumed

What can happen if you borrow for an investment purpose

ItemDetails
Lump-sum repaymentAs a breach of contract, you are asked to repay the remaining loan in a lump sum
Credit informationIf you cannot repay, information such as delinquency is registered and affects other borrowing
Criminal issuesA false application may, depending on its content, lead to a charge of fraud
Property priceProperties from companies that recommend improper use may be priced above market

Note that renting the home to others after purchase because you can no longer live in it due to unavoidable circumstances such as a job transfer is distinguished from improper use. In this case, notify the lender in advance and confirm how it will be handled.

Order of checks

  1. Check whether the loan you plan to take covers a home to live in or a property for rent.
  2. If someone recommends that "you can buy an investment property with Flat 35," do not deal with that company.
  3. If you buy a property for rent, calculate income and expenses on the terms of an investment loan.
  4. If you need to rent out a home you already bought with a housing loan, notify the lender.

From here on, this is my opinion

I think talk of using Flat 35 for investment leads people to misjudge on the single point of a low interest rate. The loss when you are asked for a lump-sum repayment is far larger than the difference in interest rates.

Sources (in Japanese)

Drunken WangLiving memory of the times

Wang here. If you know you can't go by feel, your nose works well. The source of that smell lies in who this loan is for and by what mechanism it is made cheap.

What I remember is October 2003 (Heisei 15). The government started a mechanism to buy private banks' long-term fixed-rate housing loans. The banks let go of the loans they made and lightened their load, and the buying side bundled them and sold them to investors. That way, loans whose interest rate doesn't change for thirty or thirty-five years became something even an ordinary office worker could borrow. That was the beginning of Flat 35. Since the government lends a hand, the borrowers are limited to people buying a home for themselves or their relatives to live in. The cheapness comes attached as support for people who live there.

From the bank's side, it's simple. A loan on a home to live in is repaid by the borrower to protect their own life. A loan on a home to rent out sways in its repayment depending on whether rent comes in. It's only right to put a high interest rate on a swaying loan, and that's why investment loans are expensive. Saying you'll live there and borrowing the cheaper one is the same as putting a non-swaying price tag on swaying contents.

Let me tell you about the boat crossing over from Manchuria. The blankets handed out when we boarded were set at one per person. There was a man who boarded hugging two, thinking he could sell them at the port for cash. The crew found him, took both away, and he spent that night shivering on deck. I wrapped myself in my one blanket and thought, I won't end up like that.

Back to the main point. Reading the written answer to the Diet in June 2019 (Reiwa 1), the system side had also taken steps. From November 2018 (Heisei 30), the Agency called out on its own website and in newspaper ads that "it cannot be used for investment properties," and from April 2019 (Heisei 31), at the time of application, it began confirming with a signature and seal that the applicant had been told it can't be used for investment and accepted that. From May 2019 (Reiwa 1), it also began picking out suspicious cases and investigating whether people really live there. Break the rule, and you're asked to repay the rest all at once.

Times change, but people's habits don't. When a cheap price tag catches the eye, they stop reading the fine print on its back. From 2019 (Heisei 31), applicants themselves have been acknowledging that they read that fine print. Saying "I didn't know" afterward won't pass.

So there's one thing for you to do. Whichever loan you apply for, before signing, get a copy of the application and read the box that says "will live there" again with your own eyes. If what's written there isn't true, close the papers right then and there.

Liquor is the same. Masu sake at a bar is cheap because that's the price for drinking it at that bar. Even if you ask them to fill a big bottle for you to take home, it won't be the same price. The price tag even says where you drink it. Though for me, it tastes good wherever I drink. Ka-ka-ka-ka.

(Updated 2026.10.14)

Read a little deeper